Q: Who Predicted a Tigers-Giants World Series?

October 23, 2012  |  Sports

A: No one.

Well, at least none of the 58 baseball pundits we tracked from ESPN and Sports Illustrated. While eight pundits picked the Tigers to win the American League and six picked to Giants to win the National League, not a single one picked the combination. Note that both teams were among the favorites to win their respective pennants, with Vegas handicapping the Tigers at 3-to-1 odds and the Giants at 7-to-1.

MLB Preseason Predictions (2012)

AJ Mass, ESPNDetroitAtlanta
Colin Cowherd, ESPN DetroitSt. Louis
Jayson Stark, ESPNDetroitSt. Louis
John Kruk, ESPNDetroitMilwaukee
Jorge Arangure Jr., ESPNDetroitAtlanta
Kevin Goldstein, ESPNDetroitCincinnati
Peter Pascarelli, ESPN DetroitArizona
Tony Jackson, ESPNDetroitPhiladelphia
Albert Chen, SITexasSan Francisco
Enrique Rojas, ESPNLA AngelsSan Francisco
Jim Caple, ESPNLA AngelsSan Francisco
Stephania Bell, ESPN Tampa BaySan Francisco
Stephen Cannella, SI LA AngelsSan Francisco
Tom Verducci, SILA AngelsSan Francisco
Aaron Boone, ESPNLA AngelsPhiladelphia
Adam Rubin, ESPN NY YankeesWashington
Amanda Rykoff, ESPNLA AngelsArizona
Andrew Marchand, ESPNTexasPhiladelphia
Barry Larkin, ESPNLA AngelsArizona
Ben Reiter, SI TexasMiami
Buster Olney, ESPNTampa BayArizona
Carolina Guillen, ESPN LA AngelsPhiladelphia
Christina Kahrl, ESPNLA AngelsArizona
Cliff Corcoran, SI NY YankeesSt. Louis
Curt Schilling, ESPNLA AngelsPhiladelphia
Dan Shulman, ESPNLA AngelsArizona
Dan Szymborski, ESPNTexasPhiladelphia
Dave Cameron, ESPNNY YankeesSt. Louis
David Kull, ESPNLA AngelsArizona
David Schoenfield, ESPNTexasMilwaukee
Doug Glanville, ESPNLA AngelsArizona
Doug Padilla, ESPNLA AngelsPhiladelphia
Eric Karabell, ESPNTampa BayPhiladelphia
Jason Churchill, ESPNTexasCincinnati
Javier Maymi, ESPNTampa BayMiami
Jerry Crasnick, ESPNTexasArizona
Jim Bowden, ESPNLA AngelsArizona
Joe Lemire, SI TexasPhiladelphia
Jon Sciambi, ESPNTampa BayPhiladelphia
Jonah Keri, ESPNNY YankeesPhiladelphia
Karl Ravech, ESPNBostonArizona
Keith Law, ESPNTexasAtlanta
Mark Mulder, ESPNLA AngelsArizona
Mark Saxon, ESPN LA AngelsSt. Louis
Mark Simon, ESPNLA AngelsSt. Louis
Marty Bernoski, ESPNTexasArizona
Matt Meyers, ESPNTampa BayArizona
Matt Szefc, ESPNNY YankeesPhiladelphia
Matthew Berry, ESPNLA AngelsPhiladelphia
Mel Antonen, SI LA AngelsArizona
Orel Hershiser, ESPNTampa BayArizona
Pedro Gomez, ESPNLA AngelsCincinnati
Richard Durrett, ESPNTexasPhiladelphia
Rick Sutcliffe, ESPNTexasWashington
Steve Berthiaume, ESPNLA AngelsArizona
Ted Keith, SI NY YankeesPhiladelphia
Terry Francona, ESPNLA AngelsPhiladelphia
Tristan Cockcroft, ESPNTampa BayCincinnati


Following the World Series, we will post an in-depth recap of how the MLB pundits performed in 2012 and update our $1 Yield Rankings.






  1. So the Vegas odds of this match-up was 1/21, if futures odds didn’t have juice in them. Usually the implied odds add up to 200%, implying the real odds of this match-up was 1/42. So, while amusing, 0/58 is not terribly surprising, especially when you consider the pundits are making a straight-up pick and not getting odds for their selection, skewing them away from relative underdogs like the Giants.

  2. I like what you guys are up too. Such clever work
    and exposure! Keep up the very good works guys I’ve incorporated you guys to my blogroll.


  1. Trying to Pick Winners | Above the Market
  2. Why has baseball become so hard to predict? | PunditTracker Blog
  3. MLB Pundits: 2012 Performance, Updated Rankings | PunditTracker Blog

Leave a Reply

  1. Have a pundit you would like us to track? Or some general feedback on the site? Let us know!